Welcome to vVv Gaming

Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.

  • Announcements

    • vVv Bagzli

      We have moved to Discord   08/04/2016

      There has been a strong desire among the community to migrate to Discord for quite some time. As of today, our community will be using Discord and as a result, we will no longer be actively using our TeamSpeak Server.  The TeamSpeak server will temporarily stay active to help inform all of our move to Discord. Within the next couple of months, it will be shut down completely.  For a quick invite to our new Discord server, you can click here.  
      For a full detailed guide visit http://www.vVv-Gaming.com/Discord
    • vVv Bagzli

      New Supersonic Series Start Time   10/17/2016

      We would like to thank everyone who participated in our recent survey regarding the start time of our tournaments.  After reviewing responses from the survey sent out to tournament participants we have decided to make changes to the start time of our events to try to better accommodate everyone.  Beginning on Monday, October 24th, all of our tournaments will start an hour earlier - at 8PM Eastern.  This means that registration will close at 7:30 EST, and that check-in starts at 7:30 EST and closes at 7:45 EST.
  • entries
    20
  • comments
    94
  • views
    38,199

Titanfall is the most important FPS of this decade

vVv OrganicBear

1,674 views

Let me preface this by saying I've been playing games for a long time. Not as long as some, but since Quake came out in the early 90s and massively competitive multiplayer was born. I'm going to borrow on that experience to make my case for why I think Titanfall is the most important FPS of this decade.

The Wrong Questions

I see a lot of people arguing about whether Titanfall is the CoD killer. I'm going to tell you that is the wrong question. CoD has consistently failed to engage its audience since CoD4. The most recent release, CoD: Ghosts is so underwhelming as a title that many CoD players don't actually enjoy playing it. The only reason CoD hasn't died already is because it is entrenched so firmly in the competitive scene that the community will keep playing it regardless of how enjoyable the gameplay is or isn't.

There's no alternative that fills the competitive niche the way CoD does, at least for the competitive console FPS community. Given CoD's history of releasing lackluster titles that do little more than tweak the graphics and add a new set of maps, it doesn't matter if a new game can "kill CoD". The real question is: can a console FPS deliver new and exciting gameplay mechanics that make console FPS fun to play again?

To that question, I give a resounding yes. Titanfall's gameplay is unlike any other FPS I've played. There are similarities to CoD, especially in the aiming and firing of most of the weapons revealed in the beta, but that's about where the similarities end. And it's not just that the gameplay is new, it's also GOOD. It felt natural to run around on walls and double jump my way across the map. Even as a life-long PC gamer who has two-left thumbs, it felt good to jump into windows and climb skyscrapers, or jump on the backs of the huge titans that roam the maps. And it felt natural that I'd be able to do these things in the game.

But is it competitive? This is another question that I see asked a lot. Again, the answer is that this is the wrong question. Name for me one successful game that was designed to be competitive from the first release of the series. In fact, other than Shootmania, there really hasn't been any other game that was designed specifically with competitive features in mind, and Shootmania flopped hard.

One could also argue that Black Ops 2 was designed to be competitive, although as a sequel at the end of a long string of CoD titles it isn't realistic to compare BO2 to Titanfall. Also, BO2 was replaced by CoD: Ghosts. While BO2 was a noteworthy success, developer pressure forced the competitive scene to move on to CoD: Ghosts, the game that no one likes. Ghosts removed all of the competitive features that the community loved. With that kind of history, I think the more important question CoD players should be asking is: why do I think Titanfall will be any less of a success due to a lack of competitive features when CoD wantonly adds and removes the same competitive features almost randomly?

On the other hand, if I list games that were developed with the purpose of creating a fun player experience and enjoyable gameplay mechanics, the list would look something like:

  • Starcraft, Starcraft: Brood War, and Starcraft 2,
  • League of Legends,
  • DotA and Dota2,
  • CoD4,
  • Counterstrike

That's right, every major successful esport that has endured for the past decade and the biggest esports titles still to this day. Do I even need to elaborate on this point? Who cares if the game was designed to be competitive on release. If the game is a success and people want to play it competitively, then it will become an esport. There is no magic formula or set of features that are prerequisites in order for a title to be successful competitively other than that people want to play the game and see it played competitively. Something that I feel Titanfall delivers in a big way.

The Realism Trap

For a long time CoD has tried to fulfill the fantasy of a "realistic" war simulator. The problem is, the thing they are trying to simulate isn't fun for most people. It takes creativity to make a game fun, not a dogmatic adherence to realism. For example, one of my favorite mechanics in FPS games has always been rocket jumping. It gives you tactical and mobile superiority and makes the game more exciting and fast-paced. No where in reality would you EVER see someone point a rocket launcher on the ground in order to perform aerial acrobatics. It's fun in part because it is divorced from reality. It allows me to exist in a world that is not constrained by the limits of everyday life.

The movement in Titanfall has found a way to faithfully reproduce that feeling of mobility. Along with a few other really cool features (like cloaking), this game is just extremely fun to play. And it's fun to play because it escapes from the "realistic" trope and focuses instead on fun gameplay elements. For this reason, I do not have much faith that CoD ever CAN innovate in a way that meaningfully adds interesting new gameplay elements.

This Has All Happened Before...

What I see people in the CoD community saying is the same thing that SC2 fans were saying about LoL in 2010. "The game is too simple", "it's for children", "the skill cap is too low", "it's not as competitive". I think Blizzard has shown us that when you focus your development efforts on creating a competitive title at the expense of solid gameplay, you lose. Just flat out you lose. That doesn't mean that SC2 is dead, not fun to play, or that it's not a solid competitive game, but look at how big LoL has become in comparison. If you aren't focused on creating an enjoyable experience for the person playing the game, then it doesn't matter how many competitive features there are or how high the skillcap is, you won't be as successful as the guy who is creating a fun, engaging game.

So will Titanfall kill CoD? Only in the sense that LoL killed SC2, which is to say, not really. SC2 still has a pretty healthy competitive scene and lots of people follow it and watch the game. But, barring some disaster, I really do believe Titanfall will eclipse CoD in the competitive scene in much the same way LoL has eclipsed SC2. In 10 years I think we'll all still be playing Titanfall or its successors, but I do not believe that CoD will still be around given its current trajectory—with or without Titanfall.

What About Hype?

So then how much of this is just hype and how much of it is real? Believe me, I have been around to see games hyped beyond realistic expectations before and I do not see the same patterns here. Halo Reach was hailed as the game that was going to save the ailing Halo franchise and dying competitive scene, but the developers failed to deliver. Why is that? The sad reality is that, aside from some slick graphical updates, Reach was essentially the same game as every other Halo that has ever been released.

As a spectator, I've never sat down at MLG to watch a Halo match and thought "Wow, this looks way more fun and exciting than the previous version". I can only imagine how repetitive and stale it must have gotten for true competitors who sat down to practice and grind for hours on a regular basis. Without sufficiently complex gameplay mechanics, the game simply doesn't engage an audience that has mastered lining up the crosshairs and pulling the trigger.

The same thing happened with Rift. Everyone hailed it as the WoW killer due to the "Rift" feature that would spawn mini-raid encounters at random locations around the world. This sounds really neat, but when you are operating with the same basic mechanics of target, push buttons, repeat, then even new features seem stale and repetitive. Rift didn't fail to kill WoW because of a lack of new ideas, but because, ultimately, it didn't offer a new experience for the user playing the game.

And that is why I don't think that there is just hype surrounding Titanfall. The gameplay IS different. The experience for players IS good. And with all the wall running, double jumping, and complex titan battles, there will be an enormous amount to learn and improve upon for the competitive player. Maps are no longer a two-dimensional series of boxes and corridors, but now are a three-dimensional puzzle to be navigated and exploited by the smarter, more experienced player. It's no longer about who has the better ping or who can set their crosshairs on who faster, but who can maneuver better and gain an advantage through superior mobility. And it's not enough to just have better gun skill, but which team can manage and coordinate their titans to gain an advantage before having to eject and start over.

Respawn has taken a genre that was previously defined by simple point-and-click mechanics, and created a game that is engaging strategically and tactically. They have taken a genre that was focused too hard on realism and created a game that is fun and complex. They have redefined what an FPS is and what it will take to be a good FPS player. THAT is why Titanfall is the most important FPS of this decade. I hope you'll join us while we participate in this historic game!




15 Comments


I would play with everyone at vVv but sadly I'm on pc (sarcasm on sadly) doesn't mean I'm not getting it but it does mean I won't be playing with the bulk of y'all. Also amazing write up this has made me absolutely want to buy this game.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I think you nailed it Sugarbear :)

I do think console FPS players are starting to revert back to when Halo was big just before we wanted realism.

 

I'm willing to say that this game is realistic in a future sense.  I do see these outfits and titans in Titanfall possibly being used in the distant future.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I think you nailed it Sugarbear :)

I do think console FPS players are starting to revert back to when Halo was big just before we wanted realism.

 

I'm willing to say that this game is realistic in a future sense.  I do see these outfits and titans in Titanfall possibly being used in the distant future.

I definitely agree that there is a lot of possibility of the jetpacks and titans someday being real, but for now they exist outside of what I would consider "everyday life".  That's part of the reason it's so much fun.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Very good read. Can't say I know enough about the game to really agree or disagree with you yet, but it's one I'll definitely be keeping on my radar.

Share this comment


Link to comment

while I do think titanfall is a good and very fun game. I actually would NOT like to see it go competitive. It would be a kick in the gut to any fps player to see a game like titanfall become competitive. I say game "like titanfall" because of it's game modes. Nobody wants to watch people spam abilities and missiles all over the place. The game doesn't have many real things to focus on as a spectator besides the mechs, and lets be honest. They get old watching each other fight after the first few times. Much more fun game to play casually then competitively in my opinion, and should just stay casual. Focus on the real comp games like cs x)

B Easy likes this

Share this comment


Link to comment

while I do think titanfall is a good and very fun game. I actually would NOT like to see it go competitive. It would be a kick in the gut to any fps player to see a game like titanfall become competitive. I say game "like titanfall" because of it's game modes. Nobody wants to watch people spam abilities and missiles all over the place. The game doesn't have many real things to focus on as a spectator besides the mechs, and lets be honest. They get old watching each other fight after the first few times. Much more fun game to play casually then competitively in my opinion, and should just stay casual. Focus on the real comp games like cs x)

I agree with you completely here.  Competitive isn't just about the competitive aspect of the game for the players, it has to be exciting for people to watch as well.  More games like CS, or at least with game modes similar to that of CS.  The suspense of a good "bomb plant and defuse" game mode cannot be beat with mechs.

Share this comment


Link to comment

while I do think titanfall is a good and very fun game. I actually would NOT like to see it go competitive. It would be a kick in the gut to any fps player to see a game like titanfall become competitive. I say game "like titanfall" because of it's game modes. Nobody wants to watch people spam abilities and missiles all over the place. The game doesn't have many real things to focus on as a spectator besides the mechs, and lets be honest. They get old watching each other fight after the first few times. Much more fun game to play casually then competitively in my opinion, and should just stay casual. Focus on the real comp games like cs x)

I couldn't disagree more. I think the spectator potential for Titanfall is waaaaay more promising than what you're describing here. Imagine watching two people duel while running around on walls and double jumping to juke each other. Imagine it's 1v1 with one titan vs one guy and he pulls off the jump onto the back of the titan and forces the other pilot to eject and duke it out on the ground. There's so much potential for hype plays and moments in this game. Oversimplifying it to "missiles and spam abilities" isn't really accurate at all.

Share this comment


Link to comment

There's also the option if titans are out to make smaller maps and it would play like a steroid up version of rainbow six v2.  There's so many possibilities. From what I've seen titans are best used auto piloted.  We do that and dominate on the ground.  There's lots of

new game modes they can come up with as well.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I couldn't disagree more. I think the spectator potential for Titanfall is waaaaay more promising than what you're describing here. Imagine watching two people duel while running around on walls and double jumping to juke each other. Imagine it's 1v1 with one titan vs one guy and he pulls off the jump onto the back of the titan and forces the other pilot to eject and duke it out on the ground. There's so much potential for hype plays and moments in this game. Oversimplifying it to "missiles and spam abilities" isn't really accurate at all.

Well that is true and could be very exciting as you explained. It's definitely a unique aspect of the game. But just out of experience in the fps scene I couldn't imagine people being able to run around freely and make such plays, only rare occasions. There would most likely be one dominant team comp and I feel strategies would be based around group play keeping their mech alive. Unless your playing domination, which spreading out would be more rewarding as you need to cap the bases. That could work, but then again, Domination hasn't ever really been a spectator favorite. I could eat my words but that's my two cents.

 

It's definitely the base of a good game and has potential. But until I see either the developers come out with more basic fundamental game modes or modders do it I don't think I'll be convinced it's a competitive game.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Well that is true and could be very exciting as you explained. It's definitely a unique aspect of the game. But just out of experience in the fps scene I couldn't imagine people being able to run around freely and make such plays, only rare occasions. There would most likely be one team comp and I feel strategies would be based around group play keeping their mech alive. Unless your playing domination, which spreading out would be more rewarding as you need to cap the bases. That could work, but then again, Domination hasn't ever really been a spectator favorite. I could eat my words but that's my two cents.

 

It's definitely the base of a good game and has potential. But until I see either the developers come out with more basic fundamental game modes or modders do it I don't think I'll be convinced it's a competitive game.

That's your problem. You're relying on your experience in the FPS genre. But I'm telling you this game and the motion is NOTHING like CoD or any other FPS that you're used to.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Sugarbear, you nailed it. I doubt anyone who hates actually played it. CS is just too dated.

 

Also, hate to state the obvious:

This is easy for me. People move faster in Titanfall. The faster people move, the harder they are to kill. Titanfall > CoD

Share this comment


Link to comment

Sugarbear, you nailed it. I doubt anyone who hates actually played it. CS is just too dated.

 

Also, hate to state the obvious:

This is easy for me. People move faster in Titanfall. The faster people move, the harder they are to kill. Titanfall > CoD

While the game is dated it's admirable in a sense. No fps game has come close the amount of finesse it takes to kill people consistently at a professional level. I agree with you though, Titanfall > cod, much more interesting game. Needs community modding to reach full potential though! 

Share this comment


Link to comment

The one thing that makes Titanfall such a good game to play is how fluid everything is, (at least from my experience on the computer) it’s fairly fast paced but it’s not a "jerky" shooter either. The closest game that I can compare this to that I really enjoyed as a FPS is Unreal Tournament to me the feel is similar the movement is solid and everything just seems to go, you don’t have a jerky and twitchy feel to your movement like COD, Battlefield and some of the other FPS that I have experienced.

Also everyone matters, As a pilot you can take down a Titan without being in your Titan so it still gives you a feeling of purpose other than just trying to get into a Mech to take something down. There is alot more diversity in how to strategize your point taking for example you and your titan on autopilot at a capture point can defend it fairly well while your teammates take other areas of the map. The Maps have a good design and feel to it, and from my observation so far there are no real "Camp" spots where u can stay all day and snipe people effortlessly. There is always constant movement in the game so the pace dont get stale to me its a It's a nice change of pace and after at least 6 months of tweaking and adjusting and getting a private match making system put into place I think that this would become a good entery into esports.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now